As has probably not gone unnoticed, I’m a bit of a Fiona Apple fan. In fact, I’m one of those Fiona Apple idiots, one of those people that belong to her core fan group, a group of people so obsessed with her work, her character, her being, that it sometimes scares me a little.
Listening to her art is still one of the most pleasurable past times for me. Listening to and watching interviews with her is one of the most entertaining things there is, because she isn’t media trained, and as such, comes across natural, unedited. Watching her perform is simply mindblowing - she’s not singing her songs, she’s engulfing herself in them, she’s reliving the tales told in the words, right there on stage, and you can taste it.
One of the controversial discussions among Fiona fans is which version of Extraordinary Machine is better - the leaked, unfinished Jon Brion version, or the actually released, finalised Elizondo record. Most of the people in the scary obsessed group of fans swear by the leaked Brion version.
I don’t.
A confession: I’ve never even heard it. Badum-tish.
The reason is simple. Fiona has made it clear that she wasn’t happy with the Brion version. It was too much Brion, and too little Fiona. Brion is an amazing producer, an amazing musician, and he did a great and outstanding job on Fiona’s When The Pawn, but for some reason, Fiona didn’t like the results when it came to Extraordinary Machine. She cancelled the project, and later on decided to start over, this time with producer Mike Elizondo.
This became the released version of Extraordinary Machine, the version that I proudly have in the prime position in my record collection as the limited-edition dual-disc version, which contains a DVD side with emotional and very cosy live material recorded at Club Largo.
Anyway, I have 100% confidence in Fiona. She knows what’s best for me, as one of her most devout fans and admirers. She said she didn’t like the Brion version, and recorded a new and apparently very different version of the album that she did like. And that’s enough reason for me to ignore the illegal bootleg release. I’ve never heard it, and I’m not going to either.
And I think it’s this blind faith in Fiona that makes the biggest and most devout Fiona fan in the world.